Antique Advertising
Select category
Select category
Badges, Buttons, Pins and Watch Fobs
Baking (Powder, Flour, Cocoa and Oats)
Beer and Breweriana
Beer Signs
Books, Catalogs and Ephemera
Bottles and Jars
Boxes and Crates
Calendars
Candy
Ceramics and Glass
Clocks and Watches
Clothing and Textile
Coffee and Tea
Comic Character
Condoms
Dental/Medicinal
Door Pushes
Farming/Agriculture
Gum
Ice Cream and Dairy
Labels
Match Holders / Scratchers / Matchbox Holders
Match Safes
Maxfield Parrish
Misc.
Nut and Chocolate
Oil and Gas
Oil Cans
Paperweights
Peanut Butter
Pocket Mirrors
Political / Fraternal Organization
Porcelain Signs
Posters
Powder/Talcum Tin
Salesman's Sample/Patent Model
Shaving/Barbershop
Signs
Smoking Accessories
Soda
Spice Tins
Spices
Sporting (Hunting, Fishing, Ammo)
Sports
Store Displays
Thermometers
Tins
Tobacco
Tobacco Tins
Toys, Banks, Games, Dolls & Puzzles
Transportation
Trays and Art Plates
Uncategorized Items
Veterinary
Search
User Guide
Facebook
Pinterest
Menu
User Guide
Home
Price Guide
Auctions
Current Auction
Past Auctions
Consignment
Blog
About
Contact
Back to products
Peanut Butter
Home
Peanut Butter
Showing 1–100 of 185 results
Show sidebar
Show
12
24
48
100
Default sorting
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Close
Alton Peanut Butter Tin
$
412.50
Close
andrew Kuehn Peanut Butter Pail
$
1,210.00
Close
Armour Meats Store Display
$
6,875.00
Close
Armour’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
133.10
Close
Armour’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
176.00
Close
Armour’s Peanut Butter Sign
$
1,155.00
Close
Armour’s Peanut Butter Sign
$
1,705.00
Close
Armour’s Veribest Peanut Butter Pail
$
259.60
Close
Armour’s Veribest Peanut Butter Pail
$
184.00
Close
Armour’s Veribest Peanut Butter Tin
$
110.00
Close
Armour’s Veribest Peanut Butter Tin
$
82.60
Close
Armours Veribest Peanut Butter Pail
$
69.00
Close
Barbour’s Peanut Butter Tin
$
44.00
Close
Battleship Peanut Butter Pail
$
302.50
Close
Bayle Peanut Butter Pail
$
99.00
Close
Bayle Peanut Butter Pail
$
715.00
Close
Bayle Peanut Butter Pail
$
242.00
Close
Bayle Peanut Butter Pail
$
143.00
Close
Beaver Peanut Butter Pail
$
605.00
Close
Beech-Nut Peanut Butter Sign
$
121.00
Close
Big Sister Peanut Butter Pail
$
176.00
Close
Big Sister Peanut Butter Pail
$
603.75
Close
Billie Boy Peanut Butter Pail
$
242.00
Close
Brownie Peanut Butter Pail
$
2,070.00
Close
Buffalo Brand Peanut Butter Pail
$
264.00
Close
Buffalo Peanut Butter Pail
$
165.00
Close
Buffalo Peanut Butter Pail
$
172.50
Close
Buffalo Peanut Butter Pail
$
345.00
Close
Buffalo Peanut Butter Tin
$
253.00
Close
Bunny Peanut Butter Pail
$
426.80
Close
Bunny Peanut Butter Pail
$
1,265.00
Close
Bunny Peanut Butter Pail
$
546.25
Close
C.W.G. Peanut Butter Pail
$
577.50
Close
Capitol Peanut Butter Pail
$
121.00
Close
Chef Peanut Butter Tin
$
154.00
Close
Chisca Peanut Butter Pail
$
99.00
Close
Clark’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
687.50
Close
Clarks Peanut Butter Pail
$
632.50
Close
Consumer’s Best Peanut Butter Pail
$
1,495.00
Close
Cream Dove Peanut Butter Mirror
$
431.25
Close
Credo Peanut Butter Pail
$
44.00
Close
Crown Jewel Peanut Butter Pail
$
66.00
Close
Eatagood Peanut Butter Pail
$
176.00
Close
Eatsum Peanut Butter Pail
$
44.00
Close
Elephant Kind Peanut Tin
$
69.00
Close
Empress Peanut Butter Tin
$
330.00
Close
Fi-Na-St Peanut Butter Pail
$
66.00
Close
Forster’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
70.80
Close
Fort Bedford Peanut Butter Mirror
$
126.50
Close
Fort Bedford Peanut Butter Tin
$
121.00
Close
Frontier Peanut Butter Cup
$
46.00
Close
Giant Salted Peanuts Pail
$
385.00
Close
Gold Medal Peanut Butter Tin
$
132.00
Close
Happy Home Peanut Butter Pail
$
176.00
Close
Happy Home Peanut Butter Tin
$
276.00
Close
Heinz Peanut Butter Sign
$
305.80
Close
Hoppingtot Peanut Butter Pail
$
220.00
Close
Jack Sprat Peanut Butter Pail
$
373.75
Close
Jack Sprat Peanut Butter Pail
$
1,210.00
Close
Jackie Coogan Kid Candy Pail
$
149.50
Close
Jackie Coogan Peanut Butter Pail
$
522.50
Close
Jackie Coogan Peanut Butter Pail
$
184.00
Close
Jackie Coogan Peanut Butter Pail
$
207.00
Close
Jackie Coogan Peanut Butter Pail
$
264.50
Close
Jackie Coogan Peanut Butter Tin
$
218.50
Close
Jackie Coogan Peanut Butter Tin
$
230.00
Close
Jo-Beth Peanut Butter Pail
$
431.25
Close
Jumbo Peanut Butter Glass Jar
$
198.00
Close
Jumbo Peanut Butter Jar Bank
$
517.50
Close
Jumbo Peanut Butter Jars
$
161.00
Close
Jumbo Peanut Butter Pail
$
1,650.00
Close
Kidd’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
577.50
Close
Larkin Peanut Butter Pail
$
99.00
Close
Mac Laren Peanut Butter Cup
$
106.20
Close
Maclaren’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
687.50
Close
Majestic Peanut Butter Pail
$
385.00
Close
Marvel Peanut Butter Pail
$
661.25
Close
Meadow Sweet Peanut Butter Pail
$
118.00
Close
Meadow-Sweet Peanut Butter Pail
$
198.00
Close
Miniature Peanut Butter Tin
$
165.00
Close
Minneopa Peanut Butter Pail
$
431.25
Close
Monadnock Peanut Butter Pail
$
242.00
Close
Monadnock Peanut Butter Pail
$
275.00
Close
Monadnock Peanut Butter Pail
$
115.00
Close
Monadnock Peanut Butter Pail
$
80.50
Close
Monarch Peanut Butter Pail
$
198.00
Close
Monarch Peanut Butter Pail
$
253.00
Close
Monarch Peanut Butter Store Tin
$
862.50
Close
Monarch Peanut Butter Tin
$
302.50
Close
Monarch Peanut Butter Tin
$
126.50
Close
Monarch Teenie Weenie Peanut Butter Pail
$
198.00
Close
Monarch Teenie Weenie Peanut Butter Pail
$
212.40
Close
Monarch Teenie Weenie Peanut Butter Tin
$
302.50
Close
Monarch Teenie Weenie Popcorn Pail
$
316.25
Close
Morris Supreme Peanut Butter Pail
$
132.00
Close
Morris Supreme Peanut Butter Pail
$
161.00
Close
Mosemann’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
137.50
Close
Mosemann’s Peanut Butter Pail
$
110.00
Close
Nash’s Peanut Butter Tin
$
89.10
Close
National Peanut Butter Pail
$
66.00
*Click photo for more information
Search
Home
Price Guide
Auctions
Current Auction
Past Auctions
Consignment
Blog
About
Contact
Scroll To Top
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Accept
